Above-Ground vs Underground Propane Tanks: Which Is Best?

  1. Cost Factors
  2. Appearance and Aesthetics
  3. Safety Concerns
  4. Resistance to Weather and Environment
  5. Maintenance needs
  6. Security and Vandalism
  7. Lifespan and Durability

It will be a more important decision to choose between an above-ground and underground propane tank when you plan on using propane as a fuel for your home or business. Of course, there are pros and cons of each option, influencing everything from cost and safety to aesthetics and maintenance. That is why LP Propane wants you to make an informed decision that will better fit your needs. This article analyzes the merits and demerits of each option to aid you in your selection.

1. Cost Factors

The most apparent concern when deciding between an above-ground and underground propane tank is cost. Above-ground tanks are typically less expensive. First, installation is far simpler and requires fewer materials and labor, saving you a pretty penny immediately. Underground tanks include excavation, plus additional materials to combat corrosion and more labor, making their cost to install two to three times higher than that of an above-ground tank.

Above-ground tanks are often much cheaper to install for those with a tighter household budget. That said, the underground tank is far more expensive upon installation, although some users believe the long-term benefits – such as exposure to extreme weather conditions being lessened – make the initial difference in price worth it. Whichever tank you decide on, LP Propane offers competitive pricing on installation and maintenance, thereby streamlining the process for you and saving you money at the same time.

2. Appearance and Aesthetics

One of the leading reasons so many homeowners prefer underground propane tanks is aesthetics. Propane tanks of the above ground style may be a serviceable solution, but they generally are not an attractive visual feature on or around your home. For homeowners with beautiful gardens or landscaping, an enormous propane tank might spoil the appearance of their home. Homeowners often try to conceal them behind a colorful painting or creative landscaping, but for most, this will never have the same visual appeal as the alternative.

Of course, underground tanks have the benefit of hiding themselves beneath the ground to keep the natural appearance of your place. If aesthetic appeal is a must for you with your home or business, an underground tank could be the perfect solution for you. We understand at LP Propane that a tank’s placement affects your location’s visual appeal and are more than happy to advise you on placing that tank above or underground.

Underground or above the ground, the perfect propane tank can now be found!

3. Safety Concerns

Other important considerations for choosing an above-ground and underground propane tank are safety issues. Above ground tanks, surely, are more prone to hazards from the environment and other incidents such as extreme weather conditions, hooliganism or road accidents, hence not very suitable for a particular location which may be prone to natural calamities or is congested with traffic volume. For example, if your place happens to be in an arterial road, then a potential danger to an underground propane tank is hitting by a vehicle.

In contrast, underground tanks have less exposure and are usually safer during inclement weather and accidents. Since they are well insulated by the earth, they have a more consistent temperature, and, therefore, the possibility of propane freezing is lower in colder climates. However, one risk for underground tanks is floating, when water in these can overflow the fuel situated in the tank in flood-prone areas. Installation of the tank on a concrete slab may also help to alleviate this risk. LP Propane can provide you with suggestions on which kind of tank would be safest for your respective location or requirements.

4. Resistance to Weather and Environment

A major factor in which propane tank is the right choice for you will be the environment that it resides in. Above-ground tanks are exposed to changing environmental conditions and temperatures. In colder climates, this exposure can have an effect of reduced efficiency as the effectiveness of propane is less at lower temperatures. However, if in a flood-prone area, an above-ground tank may be safer, as it is less likely to float away.

Underground tanks are less sensitive to temperature because the earth provides natural insulation. They can thus be used in extremely cold and hot regions. However, if there is a tendency for floods in your area, then the floating risk needs to be examined in detail. At LP Propane, we can help you avoid risks such as keeping your underground tank anchored with anchoring systems or recommending an above-ground alternative.

5. Maintenance needs

Maintenance is also another aspect of owning a propane tank. Above-ground tanks are accessible, which makes the repairs and refilling easier and less costly. Observing the condition of the tank is simple due to its position that enables one to always follow up with routine maintenance.

Maintenance is also another aspect of owning a propane tank. Above-ground tanks are accessible, which makes the repairs and refilling easier and less costly. Observing the condition of the tank is simple due to its position that enables one to always follow up with routine maintenance.

6. Security and Vandalism

Security, for sure, is a very valid concern among homeowners whose neighborhoods are known for their high crime rates. Above ground, propane tanks are more visibly exposed and thus more susceptible to vandalism or tampering. Underground tanks, on the other hand, are not easily seen or touched, thereby decreasing the possibility of interference. Still, above-ground tanks may also be protected by way of security measures such as fencing or surveillance.

At LP Propane we know safety and security are your number one priority, and we have many products that will safeguard both above-ground and underground tanks where your fuel source is stored safely and securely.

7. Lifespan and Durability

Another thing that you need to know is the lifecycle of your propane tank. Above-ground propane tanks usually last longer because they get air exposure which helps avoid corrosion. Underground tanks are better protected from the elements, yet they suffer from more issues with corrosion over the years even with protective coatings, inspection, and maintenance. It is estimated that an average underground propane tank lasts around 20-30 years, whereas an above-ground tank can last for many decades in case it is maintained properly.

When you go with LP Propane for your tank installation, we make sure that your tank will be installed properly and maintained for a long time, whether above or underground.

Which Tank is Right for You?

Ultimately, it will depend on your personal preferences, budget, and property conditions between an above-ground or underground propane tank. Above-ground tanks are less costly and easier to maintain, hence suitable for persons with budgets or areas where aesthetics does not matter. Underground tanks, though pricey, provide better protection of water from the elements and are more aesthetically pleasing. Therefore, these are preferred by homemakers who want curb appeal on their properties.

LP Propane will guide you in choosing the right propane for your needs, whether you prefer having an above-ground or an underground tank. We provide expert installation and maintenance services to ensure that your propane system continues to operate safely and efficiently year after year.

Call LP Propane today to discuss propane needs, and let our experienced team guide you in making the right choice for your home or business.

State Fair Giveaway

$500 Worth of Propane

Be one of the first 200 New Customers to sign-up until September 15th to get $500 worth of propane, FREE! You’ll also get 1 year free tank rental when you switch!

JOIN THE IGNITE PROGRAM

NEW CUSTOMER? Fill out the New Customer Application to join IGNITE.

Save $0.05 Per Gallon with the IGNITE Program Learn more!

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
Name(Required)
Service Address(Required)
AAP Agreement(Required)
You will be contacted by a Customer Service Representative to obtain your credit card information.
Terms of Service(Required)

LP Propane Ignite Program – Terms and Conditions

1. Eligibility and Program Requirements
To qualify for and maintain enrollment in the LP Propane Ignite Program and receive the $0.05 per gallon fuel discount, the Customer must simultaneously enroll in and maintain active status in the following three core services:

Auto Fill Delivery: The Customer authorizes LP Propane to automatically monitor, schedule, and deliver propane to the designated tank when levels dictate, bypassing the standard Will Call scheduling requirements.

Auto Pay: The Customer must maintain a valid, authorized payment method on file (Credit Card, Debit Card, or ACH/Direct Draft). Invoices will be automatically drafted within 7 days after the delivery.

Paperless Billing: The Customer agrees to receive all invoices, statements, and program communications via email. Opting out of online billing or requesting paper statements will result in a $4.95 monthly fee and disqualification from the program.

2. Fuel Discount Terms

The $0.05 per gallon discount applies exclusively to the standard market rate of propane at the exact time of delivery.

The discount is applied automatically on invoice.

This discount cannot be combined with specific commercial contract pricing or volume discounts unless expressly authorized in writing by LP Propane.

3. Tank Monitoring and Delivery Access

LP Propane may utilize physical tank monitors or advanced usage-tracking algorithms to schedule deliveries.

Access Requirements: The Customer must ensure the propane tank is always completely accessible to delivery personnel and vehicles. The pathway must be free of obstacles, locked gates, debris, or unrestrained animals within a 100-foot radius.

Seasonal Maintenance: During winter months, the Customer is legally responsible for clearing snow, ice, and paths leading to the tank. If a delivery vehicle cannot safely access the tank, the delivery will be delayed, and any emergency filling fees incurred due to subsequent low fuel levels will be billed to the Customer.

4. Credit Status and Payment Failures

If an Auto Pay transaction is declined or fails for any reason (e.g., expired card, insufficient funds), the Customer must update their account billing details immediately. If the transaction remains unprocessed for 30 days despite attempts by LP Propane to contact the Customer, the account will be automatically unenrolled from the program.

If an account balance becomes past due, LP Propane reserves the right to suspend Auto Fill privileges, pause the $0.05 per gallon discount, and transition the account to a "Will Call / Cash on Delivery" basis until the account is brought current and after review and approval of LP Propane’s credit department.

5. Program Termination or Changes

Customer Termination: Removing any of the mandatory components (Auto Fill, Auto Pay, or Paperless Billing) constitutes voluntary termination from the program. If you would like to opt out of the Ignite program you must submit 30 day written notice

Company Modifications: LP Propane reserves the right to alter, modify, or terminate the Ignite Program framework, including discount amounts or underlying eligibility terms.

MM slash DD slash YYYY