Living off-grid has its pros and cons in itself, most of which related to heating. Two most preferred options are propane and wood heating. Both of them have pros and cons. When you have decided which heating method is appropriate for your off-grid lifestyle, this guide will compare the pros and cons of propane heating and wood heating, with affordability, convenience, safety, environmental impact, among other aspects.
A versatile fuel, propane can be used for a variety of things, including heating, cooking, and hot water systems. It is stored in tanks, which may be fixed on the site or portable, as with those used in RVs. It is not delivered through municipal lines like natural gas, which makes its delivery to your location dependent on truck delivery or refill from exchange tanks.
Wood heating employs stoves, fireplaces, or wood boilers. This source of heat significantly depends on the type of wood, moisture content of wood, and efficiency level of stoves. Some new, EPA-certified wood stoves are rather efficient, while old wood stoves are not as efficient and make more emission.
Installation of both heating systems can cost differently.
Basic wood stoves could run from about $1,000 up to high-efficiency models that can cost upwards of $10,000. Installation costs may include additional cost for flues, safety equipment, and permits, which of course add up to the total.
Most propane systems are cheaper to buy, usually ranging from $200 to $1,000 dollars, depending on BTU output and the type of blower system. Most people can install these themselves, but the running of propane lines requires a professional.
Wood prices vary, but a cord will run around $100 in the summer and $200 in the winter. Also factor into your costs the purchase of a chainsaw, gas and safety equipment if you are to cut your own wood.
Costs for propane vary based on your locality and seasonal demand. Some people still prefer propane because it can even be cheaper than electric heat. The cost of regular deliveries can be considered additional, but proper planning can make it work efficiently.
To operate a wood stove takes significant daily labor. You will have to refill it often during the course of the day, especially if you are heating a pretty good-sized building, certainly if you are going through the winter months. It also includes rather labor-intensive processes like cutting and splitting wood and hauling it to the stove which only becomes more so with age.
These are very low-maintenance propane-based systems. The furnace can be set, using a thermostat, to keep the desired temperature automatically. Not even fed constantly like some other models; you can leave it unattended for short periods, which will give you peace of mind in your absence.
You will need some space to keep your source of wood, which is not practical if the property is relatively small. In addition, you will need a steady supply of dry wood throughout the winter.
The storage of propane can sometimes be easier; it’s possible to position tanks in several different locations around your home; automatic delivery services are also usually included with your propane supplier, which reduces the effort for you to keep an eye on your supply.
Modern wood stoves, while reasonably safe if properly installed, will require attention to safety considerations. These include the danger of chimney fires and smoke poisoning if a wood stove fails to be maintained in good working condition. Regular inspections and cleaning are essential to avoid potential dangers.
Propane systems are considered very safe in themselves, with such features as low-oxygen shut-off systems. There is still a chance of leaks in gas pipes that may lead to explosion. Propane lines and tanks will need periodic checking to ensure safety.
Older models can be inefficient and throw out large amounts of emissions. The newer models, however, are EPA certified and burn wood cleaner, emitting less particulate matter; however, wood smoke can still affect those who suffer from respiratory conditions.
Propane is a cleaner-burning fuel compared to many fossil fuels. High-efficiency propane furnaces achieve efficiency ratings at or above 95%, and there is much lower emission. But propane is a byproduct of the natural gas extraction process, which causes its own environmental issues.
Something like this heating to the place we live bears with it a form of relationship to nature: a wood stove in winter, crackling with logs, warm and inviting. In winter, a wood stove crackling creates a warm environment but needs more effort. Propane heating does things a little differently. Along with its thermostat, a propane furnace brings the house up to temperature with so little effort.
And there are also those who would like to have both types of heating and be able to go with a hybrid system. You can use a wood stove as your main heating source and have a propane furnace as a backup, which would be a flexible and convenient option. It would allow you to experience the romance and warmth of a wood fire and ensure that your home would still be warm when you were not there or for those winter storms that just did not want to come to an end.
When it comes to propane versus wood heating, it’s more of a matter of which fits your situation better-the question of cost, convenience, safety, and environmentally conscious. Every heating method has its pros and cons, and in the case of some off-grid homeowners, finding a happy medium between the two will be the best solution.
Weigh your options and make an informed choice based on the pros and cons of this guide in relation to your lifestyle, preferences, and heating needs. LP Propane is a company dedicated to providing you with the best propane solution to fuel your home or business. It doesn’t matter whether you’re looking for a portable tank, in which you would grill, or if the tank is being used for heating your home; our staff will be with you every step of the way. Contact us today to inquire further about our propane tank options and services.
Also Read: Buying A Propane Tank Guide
