fbpx

Propane vs Electric Shop Heaters: Which Do You Want?

The choice of which heating solution will work best for your workshop typically comes down to propane or electric heaters, each with its advantages and disadvantages, leaving much of the cost, efficiency, and specifics of the situation up to the decision-maker. In this post, we will compare the benefits and drawbacks of each so that you can get a feel for which to select in your facility. At this time, wrap your arms around businesses, such as LP Propane, that have made alternative arrangements to ensure that the small and large buildings maintain warmth all year long.

Propane vs. Electric Shop Heater

-Efficiency and Power

Propane Shop Heater System

The propane heaters will be able to deliver very high output when talking about power since they will warm a room in the shortest time imaginable. If you have a big, poorly insulated space, you should see the propane shop heater raise the temperature very quickly. Propane heaters burn at extremely high temperatures to blow air at around 130°F to 140°F, providing almost instantly efficient heat. Additionally, propane works much better for much larger areas as compared to electric heat; it continues to provide constant output in high BTUs.

Electric Heaters

Electric heaters consume electrical power and change it into heat, mainly through a coil or ceramic heating element. Very efficient but does not start immediately like propane, though electric heaters are only good for small, heavily insulated rooms. Electric heaters can warm up larger rooms, but they use more fuel and energy to do the task than propane.

-Cost Comparison

Propane

Again, in terms of cost, for example, propane heating is much cheaper in most regions than electric heating. According to the U.S. Department of Energy, propane costs, on average, produce about less than electricity in BTU output, which plays into the cost-effectiveness consideration of a heating source. Although propane prices have trended upward and downward through time, propane itself is generally not sensitive to energy market price changes, which has historically driven electricity rate changes. You will likely pay less for propane to stay warm during the coldest months.

Electric

Electric heaters tend to be more costly to run because they depend on the cost of electricity in a region. Electric heaters are also more costly long-term, especially for those who live in extremely cold climates where the heater is constantly on. Installation fees may be lower for the electric heaters simply because no fuel tanks need to be purchased or filled.

-Installation and Maintenance Requirements

Propane Heaters

One of the major factors in choosing a propane heater is installing a propane tank. Depending on how large your workshop is and the frequency of heat use, you may need to store a large propane tank or have constant refills for it to continue, therefore adding extra logistics in running the operation. LP Propane is another company that can offer safe refueling, but you need to have a safe and accessible space for the tank.

Electric Heaters

Installing electric heaters is relatively easy compared to others since one can easily plug it in at any compatible electrical outlets. An electric heater is, therefore, convenient for people who do not have time for complicated systems and have too much to offer in requirements. Of course, the usage will go along with consulting about your shop’s electrical capacity because high-intensity electric heaters consume much more power than a normal outlet can provide; thus, one may demand an improvement in electric distribution.

Heat your shop the smart way. Explore top heater options and choose your perfect match!

Advantages and Disadvantages of Propane vs Electric

-Propane Shop Heater

Advantages

  • Propane heaters warm up fast and achieve high temperatures for large or uninsulated premises.
  • Generally cheaper to run than electric heaters, especially where electricity is expensive.
  • Since you keep the propane inside, they will work perfectly even if there is no power and are, therefore, more secure.

Disadvantages

  • You must keep an occupied space with a tank of propane that you refill often.
  • Propane has the side effect of giving carbon monoxide; therefore, dilation should ensure this is safe for use.

-Electric Shop Heater

Advantages

  • No fuel storage or refueling is needed; it only has to be plugged in
  • Electric heaters have fewer moving parts, which usually means lower maintenance needs.
  • An electric heater is non-toxic in small enclosed rooms, provided special ventilation has been granted.
  •  

Disadvantages

  • Electricity heaters will take a bit longer time to heat vast spaces, especially if they consist of a big but poorly isolated space
  • The power is much costlier for heating the broad interior of a building and, for this reason, can pose considerable expense
  •  

Safety and Environmental Implication

-Safety Hazards

Propane Heaters

Heaters using propane should be well-ventilated to avoid accumulating carbon monoxide in the atmosphere, and they must keep their propane tank in a safe place; leakage at the tank must also be seen. Most of the recently available propane heaters have auto-shutoff to make sure that there is absolutely no risk.

Electric Heaters

These kinds of heaters are safer because they do not have an open flame or poisonous fumes from the surrounding environment. Nevertheless, one should not overcrowd the electrical outlet for fear that it may cause the heater to overheat and fire up the electrical setup.

-Environmental Impact

Propane Heaters

The U.S. Clean Air Act defines propane as a clean fuel, and it is one of the alternative energy sources with fewer emissions than most other fossil fuels. It is also non-toxic and should not contaminate any water or soil if leaked.

Electric Heaters

The environmental impact of electric heating varies with the power grid in your locality. Electric heaters will likely have lower carbon emissions in areas where individuals are utilizing renewable sources. Electric heating is higher in greenhouse gas emissions when electricity is derived from burning coal or any other fossil fuel.

Selecting the Right Heater for Your Store

You can be sure of warm, efficient, and reliable heat in your shop if you choose the right heater. The different heating options bring unique benefits and trade-offs. You must find the best balance between them.

  1. Shop Area and Insulation
  2. Main Use
  3. Long-term Costs

1- Shop Area and Insulation

In big shops or workshops with little insulation, propane heaters are typically much more energy-efficient and economical. Warming small rooms that are relatively well-insulated with electric heaters is less feasible because they would then, with not nearly the waste of energy, simply not lose as much heat compared to propane heaters in better-insulated areas.

2- Main Use

Electric heaters are much more convenient and easier to get going on short notice if you operate your shop on shifts and/or just need space to warm occasionally. However, if you will be relying on propane heaters each day and continually, they provide a warmer effect and save money in energy usage over time.

3- Long-term Costs

A slightly higher installation cost includes installing the tank itself, but these operate cheaper, so they should, in time, be offset against their greater expense at initial installation. Electrical heaters can be somewhat of a low installation expense, but often being turned on makes them not cost-effective over a short time in terms of power costs.

Conclusion

All of their benefits hang on to what you would be looking for in the needs of your space, budget, and heating requirements. Propane shop heaters provide more intense instant heat for large or drafty areas. Companies like LP Propane make it easier to have accessible propane services to warm up your shop for a whole season. Electric heaters work very well in small, well-insulated spaces requiring minimal setup.

You can make a good-size balanced choice on whether you need it for usage or not, even based on cost expectations. Whichever you choose between propane and electric heat, you will surely improve comfort and increase productivity at work to help keep you focused, even during the coldest months of winter.